Update path lookup
[ctf.git] / common-trace-format-specification.txt
... / ...
CommitLineData
1Common Trace Format (CTF) Specification (pre-v1.8)
2
3Mathieu Desnoyers, EfficiOS Inc.
4
5The goal of the present document is to specify a trace format that suits the
6needs of the embedded, telecom, high-performance and kernel communities. It is
7based on the Common Trace Format Requirements (v1.4) document. It is designed to
8allow traces to be natively generated by the Linux kernel, Linux user-space
9applications written in C/C++, and hardware components. One major element of
10CTF is the Trace Stream Description Language (TSDL) which flexibility
11enables description of various binary trace stream layouts.
12
13The latest version of this document can be found at:
14
15 git tree: git://git.efficios.com/ctf.git
16 gitweb: http://git.efficios.com/?p=ctf.git
17
18A reference implementation of a library to read and write this trace format is
19being implemented within the BabelTrace project, a converter between trace
20formats. The development tree is available at:
21
22 git tree: git://git.efficios.com/babeltrace.git
23 gitweb: http://git.efficios.com/?p=babeltrace.git
24
25The CE Workgroup of the Linux Foundation, Ericsson, and EfficiOS have
26sponsored this work.
27
28
29Table of Contents
30
311. Preliminary definitions
322. High-level representation of a trace
333. Event stream
344. Types
35 4.1 Basic types
36 4.1.1 Type inheritance
37 4.1.2 Alignment
38 4.1.3 Byte order
39 4.1.4 Size
40 4.1.5 Integers
41 4.1.6 GNU/C bitfields
42 4.1.7 Floating point
43 4.1.8 Enumerations
444.2 Compound types
45 4.2.1 Structures
46 4.2.2 Variants (Discriminated/Tagged Unions)
47 4.2.3 Arrays
48 4.2.4 Sequences
49 4.2.5 Strings
505. Event Packet Header
51 5.1 Event Packet Header Description
52 5.2 Event Packet Context Description
536. Event Structure
54 6.1 Event Header
55 6.1.1 Type 1 - Few event IDs
56 6.1.2 Type 2 - Many event IDs
57 6.2 Event Context
58 6.3 Event Payload
59 6.3.1 Padding
60 6.3.2 Alignment
617. Trace Stream Description Language (TSDL)
62 7.1 Meta-data
63 7.2 Declaration vs Definition
64 7.3 TSDL Scopes
65 7.3.1 Lexical Scope
66 7.3.2 Static and Dynamic Scopes
67 7.4 TSDL Examples
68
69
701. Preliminary definitions
71
72 - Event Trace: An ordered sequence of events.
73 - Event Stream: An ordered sequence of events, containing a subset of the
74 trace event types.
75 - Event Packet: A sequence of physically contiguous events within an event
76 stream.
77 - Event: This is the basic entry in a trace. (aka: a trace record).
78 - An event identifier (ID) relates to the class (a type) of event within
79 an event stream.
80 e.g. event: irq_entry.
81 - An event (or event record) relates to a specific instance of an event
82 class.
83 e.g. event: irq_entry, at time X, on CPU Y
84 - Source Architecture: Architecture writing the trace.
85 - Reader Architecture: Architecture reading the trace.
86
87
882. High-level representation of a trace
89
90A trace is divided into multiple event streams. Each event stream contains a
91subset of the trace event types.
92
93The final output of the trace, after its generation and optional transport over
94the network, is expected to be either on permanent or temporary storage in a
95virtual file system. Because each event stream is appended to while a trace is
96being recorded, each is associated with a distinct set of files for
97output. Therefore, a stored trace can be represented as a directory
98containing zero, one or more files per stream.
99
100Meta-data description associated with the trace contains information on
101trace event types expressed in the Trace Stream Description Language
102(TSDL). This language describes:
103
104- Trace version.
105- Types available.
106- Per-trace event header description.
107- Per-stream event header description.
108- Per-stream event context description.
109- Per-event
110 - Event type to stream mapping.
111 - Event type to name mapping.
112 - Event type to ID mapping.
113 - Event context description.
114 - Event fields description.
115
116
1173. Event stream
118
119An event stream can be divided into contiguous event packets of variable
120size. These subdivisions have a variable size. An event packet can
121contain a certain amount of padding at the end. The stream header is
122repeated at the beginning of each event packet. The rationale for the
123event stream design choices is explained in Appendix B. Stream Header
124Rationale.
125
126The event stream header will therefore be referred to as the "event packet
127header" throughout the rest of this document.
128
129
1304. Types
131
132Types are organized as type classes. Each type class belong to either of two
133kind of types: basic types or compound types.
134
1354.1 Basic types
136
137A basic type is a scalar type, as described in this section. It includes
138integers, GNU/C bitfields, enumerations, and floating point values.
139
1404.1.1 Type inheritance
141
142Type specifications can be inherited to allow deriving types from a
143type class. For example, see the uint32_t named type derived from the "integer"
144type class below ("Integers" section). Types have a precise binary
145representation in the trace. A type class has methods to read and write these
146types, but must be derived into a type to be usable in an event field.
147
1484.1.2 Alignment
149
150We define "byte-packed" types as aligned on the byte size, namely 8-bit.
151We define "bit-packed" types as following on the next bit, as defined by the
152"Integers" section.
153
154Each basic type must specify its alignment, in bits. Examples of
155possible alignments are: bit-packed (align = 1), byte-packed (align =
1568), or word-aligned (e.g. align = 32 or align = 64). The choice depends
157on the architecture preference and compactness vs performance trade-offs
158of the implementation. Architectures providing fast unaligned write
159byte-packed basic types to save space, aligning each type on byte
160boundaries (8-bit). Architectures with slow unaligned writes align types
161on specific alignment values. If no specific alignment is declared for a
162type, it is assumed to be bit-packed for integers with size not multiple
163of 8 bits and for gcc bitfields. All other basic types are byte-packed
164by default. It is however recommended to always specify the alignment
165explicitly. Alignment values must be power of two. Compound types are
166aligned as specified in their individual specification.
167
168TSDL meta-data attribute representation of a specific alignment:
169
170 align = value; /* value in bits */
171
1724.1.3 Byte order
173
174By default, the native endianness of the source architecture the trace is used.
175Byte order can be overridden for a basic type by specifying a "byte_order"
176attribute. Typical use-case is to specify the network byte order (big endian:
177"be") to save data captured from the network into the trace without conversion.
178If not specified, the byte order is native.
179
180TSDL meta-data representation:
181
182 byte_order = native OR network OR be OR le; /* network and be are aliases */
183
1844.1.4 Size
185
186Type size, in bits, for integers and floats is that returned by "sizeof()" in C
187multiplied by CHAR_BIT.
188We require the size of "char" and "unsigned char" types (CHAR_BIT) to be fixed
189to 8 bits for cross-endianness compatibility.
190
191TSDL meta-data representation:
192
193 size = value; (value is in bits)
194
1954.1.5 Integers
196
197Signed integers are represented in two-complement. Integer alignment,
198size, signedness and byte ordering are defined in the TSDL meta-data.
199Integers aligned on byte size (8-bit) and with length multiple of byte
200size (8-bit) correspond to the C99 standard integers. In addition,
201integers with alignment and/or size that are _not_ a multiple of the
202byte size are permitted; these correspond to the C99 standard bitfields,
203with the added specification that the CTF integer bitfields have a fixed
204binary representation. A MIT-licensed reference implementation of the
205CTF portable bitfields is available at:
206
207 http://git.efficios.com/?p=babeltrace.git;a=blob;f=include/babeltrace/bitfield.h
208
209Binary representation of integers:
210
211- On little and big endian:
212 - Within a byte, high bits correspond to an integer high bits, and low bits
213 correspond to low bits.
214- On little endian:
215 - Integer across multiple bytes are placed from the less significant to the
216 most significant.
217 - Consecutive integers are placed from lower bits to higher bits (even within
218 a byte).
219- On big endian:
220 - Integer across multiple bytes are placed from the most significant to the
221 less significant.
222 - Consecutive integers are placed from higher bits to lower bits (even within
223 a byte).
224
225This binary representation is derived from the bitfield implementation in GCC
226for little and big endian. However, contrary to what GCC does, integers can
227cross units boundaries (no padding is required). Padding can be explicitly
228added (see 4.1.6 GNU/C bitfields) to follow the GCC layout if needed.
229
230TSDL meta-data representation:
231
232 integer {
233 signed = true OR false; /* default false */
234 byte_order = native OR network OR be OR le; /* default native */
235 size = value; /* value in bits, no default */
236 align = value; /* value in bits */
237 /* based used for pretty-printing output, default: decimal. */
238 base = decimal OR dec OR OR d OR i OR u OR 10 OR hexadecimal OR hex OR x OR X OR p OR 16
239 OR octal OR oct OR o OR 8 OR binary OR b OR 2;
240 /* character encoding, default: none */
241 encoding = none or UTF8 or ASCII;
242 }
243
244Example of type inheritance (creation of a uint32_t named type):
245
246typealias integer {
247 size = 32;
248 signed = false;
249 align = 32;
250} := uint32_t;
251
252Definition of a named 5-bit signed bitfield:
253
254typealias integer {
255 size = 5;
256 signed = true;
257 align = 1;
258} := int5_t;
259
260The character encoding field can be used to specify that the integer
261must be printed as a text character when read. e.g.:
262
263typealias integer {
264 size = 8;
265 align = 8;
266 signed = false;
267 encoding = UTF8;
268} := utf_char;
269
270
2714.1.6 GNU/C bitfields
272
273The GNU/C bitfields follow closely the integer representation, with a
274particularity on alignment: if a bitfield cannot fit in the current unit, the
275unit is padded and the bitfield starts at the following unit. The unit size is
276defined by the size of the type "unit_type".
277
278TSDL meta-data representation:
279
280 unit_type name:size;
281
282As an example, the following structure declared in C compiled by GCC:
283
284struct example {
285 short a:12;
286 short b:5;
287};
288
289The example structure is aligned on the largest element (short). The second
290bitfield would be aligned on the next unit boundary, because it would not fit in
291the current unit.
292
2934.1.7 Floating point
294
295The floating point values byte ordering is defined in the TSDL meta-data.
296
297Floating point values follow the IEEE 754-2008 standard interchange formats.
298Description of the floating point values include the exponent and mantissa size
299in bits. Some requirements are imposed on the floating point values:
300
301- FLT_RADIX must be 2.
302- mant_dig is the number of digits represented in the mantissa. It is specified
303 by the ISO C99 standard, section 5.2.4, as FLT_MANT_DIG, DBL_MANT_DIG and
304 LDBL_MANT_DIG as defined by <float.h>.
305- exp_dig is the number of digits represented in the exponent. Given that
306 mant_dig is one bit more than its actual size in bits (leading 1 is not
307 needed) and also given that the sign bit always takes one bit, exp_dig can be
308 specified as:
309
310 - sizeof(float) * CHAR_BIT - FLT_MANT_DIG
311 - sizeof(double) * CHAR_BIT - DBL_MANT_DIG
312 - sizeof(long double) * CHAR_BIT - LDBL_MANT_DIG
313
314TSDL meta-data representation:
315
316floating_point {
317 exp_dig = value;
318 mant_dig = value;
319 byte_order = native OR network OR be OR le;
320 align = value;
321}
322
323Example of type inheritance:
324
325typealias floating_point {
326 exp_dig = 8; /* sizeof(float) * CHAR_BIT - FLT_MANT_DIG */
327 mant_dig = 24; /* FLT_MANT_DIG */
328 byte_order = native;
329 align = 32;
330} := float;
331
332TODO: define NaN, +inf, -inf behavior.
333
334Bit-packed, byte-packed or larger alignments can be used for floating
335point values, similarly to integers.
336
3374.1.8 Enumerations
338
339Enumerations are a mapping between an integer type and a table of strings. The
340numerical representation of the enumeration follows the integer type specified
341by the meta-data. The enumeration mapping table is detailed in the enumeration
342description within the meta-data. The mapping table maps inclusive value
343ranges (or single values) to strings. Instead of being limited to simple
344"value -> string" mappings, these enumerations map
345"[ start_value ... end_value ] -> string", which map inclusive ranges of
346values to strings. An enumeration from the C language can be represented in
347this format by having the same start_value and end_value for each element, which
348is in fact a range of size 1. This single-value range is supported without
349repeating the start and end values with the value = string declaration.
350
351enum name : integer_type {
352 somestring = start_value1 ... end_value1,
353 "other string" = start_value2 ... end_value2,
354 yet_another_string, /* will be assigned to end_value2 + 1 */
355 "some other string" = value,
356 ...
357};
358
359If the values are omitted, the enumeration starts at 0 and increment of 1 for
360each entry:
361
362enum name : unsigned int {
363 ZERO,
364 ONE,
365 TWO,
366 TEN = 10,
367 ELEVEN,
368};
369
370Overlapping ranges within a single enumeration are implementation defined.
371
372A nameless enumeration can be declared as a field type or as part of a typedef:
373
374enum : integer_type {
375 ...
376}
377
378Enumerations omitting the container type ": integer_type" use the "int"
379type (for compatibility with C99). The "int" type must be previously
380declared. E.g.:
381
382typealias integer { size = 32; align = 32; signed = true } := int;
383
384enum {
385 ...
386}
387
388
3894.2 Compound types
390
391Compound are aggregation of type declarations. Compound types include
392structures, variant, arrays, sequences, and strings.
393
3944.2.1 Structures
395
396Structures are aligned on the largest alignment required by basic types
397contained within the structure. (This follows the ISO/C standard for structures)
398
399TSDL meta-data representation of a named structure:
400
401struct name {
402 field_type field_name;
403 field_type field_name;
404 ...
405};
406
407Example:
408
409struct example {
410 integer { /* Nameless type */
411 size = 16;
412 signed = true;
413 align = 16;
414 } first_field_name;
415 uint64_t second_field_name; /* Named type declared in the meta-data */
416};
417
418The fields are placed in a sequence next to each other. They each possess a
419field name, which is a unique identifier within the structure.
420
421A nameless structure can be declared as a field type or as part of a typedef:
422
423struct {
424 ...
425}
426
427Alignment for a structure compound type can be forced to a minimum value
428by adding an "align" specifier after the declaration of a structure
429body. This attribute is read as: align(value). The value is specified in
430bits. The structure will be aligned on the maximum value between this
431attribute and the alignment required by the basic types contained within
432the structure. e.g.
433
434struct {
435 ...
436} align(32)
437
4384.2.2 Variants (Discriminated/Tagged Unions)
439
440A CTF variant is a selection between different types. A CTF variant must
441always be defined within the scope of a structure or within fields
442contained within a structure (defined recursively). A "tag" enumeration
443field must appear in either the same static scope, prior to the variant
444field (in field declaration order), in an upper static scope , or in an
445upper dynamic scope (see Section 7.3.2). The type selection is indicated
446by the mapping from the enumeration value to the string used as variant
447type selector. The field to use as tag is specified by the "tag_field",
448specified between "< >" after the "variant" keyword for unnamed
449variants, and after "variant name" for named variants.
450
451The alignment of the variant is the alignment of the type as selected by the tag
452value for the specific instance of the variant. The alignment of the type
453containing the variant is independent of the variant alignment. The size of the
454variant is the size as selected by the tag value for the specific instance of
455the variant.
456
457A named variant declaration followed by its definition within a structure
458declaration:
459
460variant name {
461 field_type sel1;
462 field_type sel2;
463 field_type sel3;
464 ...
465};
466
467struct {
468 enum : integer_type { sel1, sel2, sel3, ... } tag_field;
469 ...
470 variant name <tag_field> v;
471}
472
473An unnamed variant definition within a structure is expressed by the following
474TSDL meta-data:
475
476struct {
477 enum : integer_type { sel1, sel2, sel3, ... } tag_field;
478 ...
479 variant <tag_field> {
480 field_type sel1;
481 field_type sel2;
482 field_type sel3;
483 ...
484 } v;
485}
486
487Example of a named variant within a sequence that refers to a single tag field:
488
489variant example {
490 uint32_t a;
491 uint64_t b;
492 short c;
493};
494
495struct {
496 enum : uint2_t { a, b, c } choice;
497 unsigned int seqlen;
498 variant example <choice> v[seqlen];
499}
500
501Example of an unnamed variant:
502
503struct {
504 enum : uint2_t { a, b, c, d } choice;
505 /* Unrelated fields can be added between the variant and its tag */
506 int32_t somevalue;
507 variant <choice> {
508 uint32_t a;
509 uint64_t b;
510 short c;
511 struct {
512 unsigned int field1;
513 uint64_t field2;
514 } d;
515 } s;
516}
517
518Example of an unnamed variant within an array:
519
520struct {
521 enum : uint2_t { a, b, c } choice;
522 variant <choice> {
523 uint32_t a;
524 uint64_t b;
525 short c;
526 } v[10];
527}
528
529Example of a variant type definition within a structure, where the defined type
530is then declared within an array of structures. This variant refers to a tag
531located in an upper static scope. This example clearly shows that a variant
532type definition referring to the tag "x" uses the closest preceding field from
533the static scope of the type definition.
534
535struct {
536 enum : uint2_t { a, b, c, d } x;
537
538 typedef variant <x> { /*
539 * "x" refers to the preceding "x" enumeration in the
540 * static scope of the type definition.
541 */
542 uint32_t a;
543 uint64_t b;
544 short c;
545 } example_variant;
546
547 struct {
548 enum : int { x, y, z } x; /* This enumeration is not used by "v". */
549 example_variant v; /*
550 * "v" uses the "enum : uint2_t { a, b, c, d }"
551 * tag.
552 */
553 } a[10];
554}
555
5564.2.3 Arrays
557
558Arrays are fixed-length. Their length is declared in the type
559declaration within the meta-data. They contain an array of "inner type"
560elements, which can refer to any type not containing the type of the
561array being declared (no circular dependency). The length is the number
562of elements in an array.
563
564TSDL meta-data representation of a named array:
565
566typedef elem_type name[length];
567
568A nameless array can be declared as a field type within a structure, e.g.:
569
570 uint8_t field_name[10];
571
572Arrays are always aligned on their element alignment requirement.
573
5744.2.4 Sequences
575
576Sequences are dynamically-sized arrays. They refer to a a "length"
577unsigned integer field, which must appear in either the same static scope,
578prior to the sequence field (in field declaration order), in an upper
579static scope, or in an upper dynamic scope (see Section 7.3.2). This
580length field represents the number of elements in the sequence. The
581sequence per se is an array of "inner type" elements.
582
583TSDL meta-data representation for a sequence type definition:
584
585struct {
586 unsigned int length_field;
587 typedef elem_type typename[length_field];
588 typename seq_field_name;
589}
590
591A sequence can also be declared as a field type, e.g.:
592
593struct {
594 unsigned int length_field;
595 long seq_field_name[length_field];
596}
597
598Multiple sequences can refer to the same length field, and these length
599fields can be in a different upper dynamic scope:
600
601e.g., assuming the stream.event.header defines:
602
603stream {
604 ...
605 id = 1;
606 event.header := struct {
607 uint16_t seq_len;
608 };
609};
610
611event {
612 ...
613 stream_id = 1;
614 fields := struct {
615 long seq_a[stream.event.header.seq_len];
616 char seq_b[stream.event.header.seq_len];
617 };
618};
619
620The sequence elements follow the "array" specifications.
621
6224.2.5 Strings
623
624Strings are an array of bytes of variable size and are terminated by a '\0'
625"NULL" character. Their encoding is described in the TSDL meta-data. In
626absence of encoding attribute information, the default encoding is
627UTF-8.
628
629TSDL meta-data representation of a named string type:
630
631typealias string {
632 encoding = UTF8 OR ASCII;
633} := name;
634
635A nameless string type can be declared as a field type:
636
637string field_name; /* Use default UTF8 encoding */
638
639Strings are always aligned on byte size.
640
6415. Event Packet Header
642
643The event packet header consists of two parts: the "event packet header"
644is the same for all streams of a trace. The second part, the "event
645packet context", is described on a per-stream basis. Both are described
646in the TSDL meta-data. The packets are aligned on architecture-page-sized
647addresses.
648
649Event packet header (all fields are optional, specified by TSDL meta-data):
650
651- Magic number (CTF magic number: 0xC1FC1FC1) specifies that this is a
652 CTF packet. This magic number is optional, but when present, it should
653 come at the very beginning of the packet.
654- Trace UUID, used to ensure the event packet match the meta-data used.
655 (note: we cannot use a meta-data checksum in every cases instead of a
656 UUID because meta-data can be appended to while tracing is active)
657 This field is optional.
658- Stream ID, used as reference to stream description in meta-data.
659 This field is optional if there is only one stream description in the
660 meta-data, but becomes required if there are more than one stream in
661 the TSDL meta-data description.
662
663Event packet context (all fields are optional, specified by TSDL meta-data):
664
665- Event packet content size (in bits).
666- Event packet size (in bits, includes padding).
667- Event packet content checksum. Checksum excludes the event packet
668 header.
669- Per-stream event packet sequence count (to deal with UDP packet loss). The
670 number of significant sequence counter bits should also be present, so
671 wrap-arounds are dealt with correctly.
672- Time-stamp at the beginning and time-stamp at the end of the event packet.
673 Both timestamps are written in the packet header, but sampled respectively
674 while (or before) writing the first event and while (or after) writing the
675 last event in the packet. The inclusive range between these timestamps should
676 include all event timestamps assigned to events contained within the packet.
677- Events discarded count
678 - Snapshot of a per-stream free-running counter, counting the number of
679 events discarded that were supposed to be written in the stream prior to
680 the first event in the event packet.
681 * Note: producer-consumer buffer full condition should fill the current
682 event packet with padding so we know exactly where events have been
683 discarded.
684- Lossless compression scheme used for the event packet content. Applied
685 directly to raw data. New types of compression can be added in following
686 versions of the format.
687 0: no compression scheme
688 1: bzip2
689 2: gzip
690 3: xz
691- Cypher used for the event packet content. Applied after compression.
692 0: no encryption
693 1: AES
694- Checksum scheme used for the event packet content. Applied after encryption.
695 0: no checksum
696 1: md5
697 2: sha1
698 3: crc32
699
7005.1 Event Packet Header Description
701
702The event packet header layout is indicated by the trace packet.header
703field. Here is a recommended structure type for the packet header with
704the fields typically expected (although these fields are each optional):
705
706struct event_packet_header {
707 uint32_t magic;
708 uint8_t uuid[16];
709 uint32_t stream_id;
710};
711
712trace {
713 ...
714 packet.header := struct event_packet_header;
715};
716
717If the magic number is not present, tools such as "file" will have no
718mean to discover the file type.
719
720If the uuid is not present, no validation that the meta-data actually
721corresponds to the stream is performed.
722
723If the stream_id packet header field is missing, the trace can only
724contain a single stream. Its "id" field can be left out, and its events
725don't need to declare a "stream_id" field.
726
727
7285.2 Event Packet Context Description
729
730Event packet context example. These are declared within the stream declaration
731in the meta-data. All these fields are optional. If the packet size field is
732missing, the whole stream only contains a single packet. If the content
733size field is missing, the packet is filled (no padding). The content
734and packet sizes include all headers.
735
736An example event packet context type:
737
738struct event_packet_context {
739 uint64_t timestamp_begin;
740 uint64_t timestamp_end;
741 uint32_t checksum;
742 uint32_t stream_packet_count;
743 uint32_t events_discarded;
744 uint32_t cpu_id;
745 uint32_t/uint16_t content_size;
746 uint32_t/uint16_t packet_size;
747 uint8_t stream_packet_count_bits; /* Significant counter bits */
748 uint8_t compression_scheme;
749 uint8_t encryption_scheme;
750 uint8_t checksum_scheme;
751};
752
753
7546. Event Structure
755
756The overall structure of an event is:
757
7581 - Stream Packet Context (as specified by the stream meta-data)
759 2 - Event Header (as specified by the stream meta-data)
760 3 - Stream Event Context (as specified by the stream meta-data)
761 4 - Event Context (as specified by the event meta-data)
762 5 - Event Payload (as specified by the event meta-data)
763
764This structure defines an implicit dynamic scoping, where variants
765located in inner structures (those with a higher number in the listing
766above) can refer to the fields of outer structures (with lower number in
767the listing above). See Section 7.3 TSDL Scopes for more detail.
768
7696.1 Event Header
770
771Event headers can be described within the meta-data. We hereby propose, as an
772example, two types of events headers. Type 1 accommodates streams with less than
77331 event IDs. Type 2 accommodates streams with 31 or more event IDs.
774
775One major factor can vary between streams: the number of event IDs assigned to
776a stream. Luckily, this information tends to stay relatively constant (modulo
777event registration while trace is being recorded), so we can specify different
778representations for streams containing few event IDs and streams containing
779many event IDs, so we end up representing the event ID and time-stamp as
780densely as possible in each case.
781
782The header is extended in the rare occasions where the information cannot be
783represented in the ranges available in the standard event header. They are also
784used in the rare occasions where the data required for a field could not be
785collected: the flag corresponding to the missing field within the missing_fields
786array is then set to 1.
787
788Types uintX_t represent an X-bit unsigned integer, as declared with
789either:
790
791 typealias integer { size = X; align = X; signed = false } := uintX_t;
792
793 or
794
795 typealias integer { size = X; align = 1; signed = false } := uintX_t;
796
7976.1.1 Type 1 - Few event IDs
798
799 - Aligned on 32-bit (or 8-bit if byte-packed, depending on the architecture
800 preference).
801 - Native architecture byte ordering.
802 - For "compact" selection
803 - Fixed size: 32 bits.
804 - For "extended" selection
805 - Size depends on the architecture and variant alignment.
806
807struct event_header_1 {
808 /*
809 * id: range: 0 - 30.
810 * id 31 is reserved to indicate an extended header.
811 */
812 enum : uint5_t { compact = 0 ... 30, extended = 31 } id;
813 variant <id> {
814 struct {
815 uint27_t timestamp;
816 } compact;
817 struct {
818 uint32_t id; /* 32-bit event IDs */
819 uint64_t timestamp; /* 64-bit timestamps */
820 } extended;
821 } v;
822} align(32); /* or align(8) */
823
824
8256.1.2 Type 2 - Many event IDs
826
827 - Aligned on 16-bit (or 8-bit if byte-packed, depending on the architecture
828 preference).
829 - Native architecture byte ordering.
830 - For "compact" selection
831 - Size depends on the architecture and variant alignment.
832 - For "extended" selection
833 - Size depends on the architecture and variant alignment.
834
835struct event_header_2 {
836 /*
837 * id: range: 0 - 65534.
838 * id 65535 is reserved to indicate an extended header.
839 */
840 enum : uint16_t { compact = 0 ... 65534, extended = 65535 } id;
841 variant <id> {
842 struct {
843 uint32_t timestamp;
844 } compact;
845 struct {
846 uint32_t id; /* 32-bit event IDs */
847 uint64_t timestamp; /* 64-bit timestamps */
848 } extended;
849 } v;
850} align(16); /* or align(8) */
851
852
8536.2 Event Context
854
855The event context contains information relative to the current event.
856The choice and meaning of this information is specified by the TSDL
857stream and event meta-data descriptions. The stream context is applied
858to all events within the stream. The stream context structure follows
859the event header. The event context is applied to specific events. Its
860structure follows the stream context structure.
861
862An example of stream-level event context is to save the event payload size with
863each event, or to save the current PID with each event. These are declared
864within the stream declaration within the meta-data:
865
866 stream {
867 ...
868 event.context := struct {
869 uint pid;
870 uint16_t payload_size;
871 };
872 };
873
874An example of event-specific event context is to declare a bitmap of missing
875fields, only appended after the stream event context if the extended event
876header is selected. NR_FIELDS is the number of fields within the event (a
877numeric value).
878
879 event {
880 context = struct {
881 variant <id> {
882 struct { } compact;
883 struct {
884 uint1_t missing_fields[NR_FIELDS]; /* missing event fields bitmap */
885 } extended;
886 } v;
887 };
888 ...
889 }
890
8916.3 Event Payload
892
893An event payload contains fields specific to a given event type. The fields
894belonging to an event type are described in the event-specific meta-data
895within a structure type.
896
8976.3.1 Padding
898
899No padding at the end of the event payload. This differs from the ISO/C standard
900for structures, but follows the CTF standard for structures. In a trace, even
901though it makes sense to align the beginning of a structure, it really makes no
902sense to add padding at the end of the structure, because structures are usually
903not followed by a structure of the same type.
904
905This trick can be done by adding a zero-length "end" field at the end of the C
906structures, and by using the offset of this field rather than using sizeof()
907when calculating the size of a structure (see Appendix "A. Helper macros").
908
9096.3.2 Alignment
910
911The event payload is aligned on the largest alignment required by types
912contained within the payload. (This follows the ISO/C standard for structures)
913
914
9157. Trace Stream Description Language (TSDL)
916
917The Trace Stream Description Language (TSDL) allows expression of the
918binary trace streams layout in a C99-like Domain Specific Language
919(DSL).
920
921
9227.1 Meta-data
923
924The trace stream layout description is located in the trace meta-data.
925The meta-data is itself located in a stream identified by its name:
926"metadata".
927
928The meta-data description can be expressed in two different formats:
929text-only and packet-based. The text-only description facilitates
930generation of meta-data and provides a convenient way to enter the
931meta-data information by hand. The packet-based meta-data provides the
932CTF stream packet facilities (checksumming, compression, encryption,
933network-readiness) for meta-data stream generated and transported by a
934tracer.
935
936The text-only meta-data file is a plain text TSDL description.
937
938The packet-based meta-data is made of "meta-data packets", which each
939start with a meta-data packet header. The packet-based meta-data
940description is detected by reading the magic number "0x75D11D57" at the
941beginning of the file. This magic number is also used to detect the
942endianness of the architecture by trying to read the CTF magic number
943and its counterpart in reversed endianness. The events within the
944meta-data stream have no event header nor event context. Each event only
945contains a "sequence" payload, which is a sequence of bits using the
946"trace.packet.header.content_size" field as a placeholder for its length
947(the packet header size should be substracted). The formatting of this
948sequence of bits is a plain-text representation of the TSDL description.
949Each meta-data packet start with a special packet header, specific to
950the meta-data stream, which contains, exactly:
951
952struct metadata_packet_header {
953 uint32_t magic; /* 0x75D11D57 */
954 uint8_t uuid[16]; /* Unique Universal Identifier */
955 uint32_t checksum; /* 0 if unused */
956 uint32_t content_size; /* in bits */
957 uint32_t packet_size; /* in bits */
958 uint8_t compression_scheme; /* 0 if unused */
959 uint8_t encryption_scheme; /* 0 if unused */
960 uint8_t checksum_scheme; /* 0 if unused */
961};
962
963The packet-based meta-data can be converted to a text-only meta-data by
964concatenating all the strings in contains.
965
966In the textual representation of the meta-data, the text contained
967within "/*" and "*/", as well as within "//" and end of line, are
968treated as comments. Boolean values can be represented as true, TRUE,
969or 1 for true, and false, FALSE, or 0 for false. Within the string-based
970meta-data description, the trace UUID is represented as a string of
971hexadecimal digits and dashes "-". In the event packet header, the trace
972UUID is represented as an array of bytes.
973
974
9757.2 Declaration vs Definition
976
977A declaration associates a layout to a type, without specifying where
978this type is located in the event structure hierarchy (see Section 6).
979This therefore includes typedef, typealias, as well as all type
980specifiers. In certain circumstances (typedef, structure field and
981variant field), a declaration is followed by a declarator, which specify
982the newly defined type name (for typedef), or the field name (for
983declarations located within structure and variants). Array and sequence,
984declared with square brackets ("[" "]"), are part of the declarator,
985similarly to C99. The enumeration base type is specified by
986": enum_base", which is part of the type specifier. The variant tag
987name, specified between "<" ">", is also part of the type specifier.
988
989A definition associates a type to a location in the event structure
990hierarchy (see Section 6). This association is denoted by ":=", as shown
991in Section 7.3.
992
993
9947.3 TSDL Scopes
995
996TSDL uses three different types of scoping: a lexical scope is used for
997declarations and type definitions, and static and dynamic scopes are
998used for variants references to tag fields (with relative and absolute
999path lookups) and for sequence references to length fields.
1000
10017.3.1 Lexical Scope
1002
1003Each of "trace", "stream", "event", "struct" and "variant" have their own
1004nestable declaration scope, within which types can be declared using "typedef"
1005and "typealias". A root declaration scope also contains all declarations
1006located outside of any of the aforementioned declarations. An inner
1007declaration scope can refer to type declared within its container
1008lexical scope prior to the inner declaration scope. Redefinition of a
1009typedef or typealias is not valid, although hiding an upper scope
1010typedef or typealias is allowed within a sub-scope.
1011
10127.3.2 Static and Dynamic Scopes
1013
1014A local static scope consists in the scope generated by the declaration
1015of fields within a compound type. A static scope is a local static scope
1016augmented with the nested sub-static-scopes it contains.
1017
1018A dynamic scope consists in the static scope augmented with the
1019implicit event structure definition hierarchy presented at Section 6.
1020
1021Multiple declarations of the same field name within a local static scope
1022is not valid. It is however valid to re-use the same field name in
1023different local scopes.
1024
1025Nested static and dynamic scopes form lookup paths. These are used for
1026variant tag and sequence length references. They are used at the variant
1027and sequence definition site to look up the location of the tag field
1028associated with a variant, and to lookup up the location of the length
1029field associated with a sequence.
1030
1031Variants and sequences can refer to a tag field either using a relative
1032path or an absolute path. The relative path starts with "." to ensure
1033there are no conflicts with dynamic scope names. It is relative to the
1034scope in which the variant or sequence performing the lookup is located.
1035Relative paths are only allowed to lookup within the same static scope,
1036which includes its nested static scopes. Lookups targeting parent static
1037scopes need to be performed with an absolute path.
1038
1039Absolute path lookups use the full path including the dynamic scope
1040followed by a "." and then the static scope. Therefore, variants (or
1041sequences) in lower levels in the dynamic scope (e.g. event context) can
1042refer to a tag (or length) field located in upper levels (e.g. in the
1043event header) by specifying, in this case, the associated tag with
1044<stream.event.header.field_name>. This allows, for instance, the event
1045context to define a variant referring to the "id" field of the event
1046header as selector.
1047
1048The dynamic scope prefixes are thus:
1049
1050 - Trace Packet Header: <trace.packet.header. >,
1051 - Stream Packet Context: <stream.packet.context. >,
1052 - Event Header: <stream.event.header. >,
1053 - Stream Event Context: <stream.event.context. >,
1054 - Event Context: <event.context. >,
1055 - Event Payload: <event.fields. >.
1056
1057
1058The target dynamic scope must be specified explicitly when referring to
1059a field outside of the static scope (absolute scope reference).
1060References to fields within the static scope (including local static
1061scopes and nested static scopes) can be referenced by using a relative
1062reference (starting with ".").
1063
1064As a matter of convenience, the leading "." in relative paths can be
1065omitted. In case of conflict between relative and dynamic paths, the
1066relative path is preferred. It is recommended to use the "." prefix for
1067relative paths to ensure no path name conflict can occur.
1068
1069The information available in the dynamic scopes can be thought of as the
1070current tracing context. At trace production, information about the
1071current context is saved into the specified scope field levels. At trace
1072consumption, for each event, the current trace context is therefore
1073readable by accessing the upper dynamic scopes.
1074
1075
10767.4 TSDL Examples
1077
1078The grammar representing the TSDL meta-data is presented in Appendix C.
1079TSDL Grammar. This section presents a rather lighter reading that
1080consists in examples of TSDL meta-data, with template values.
1081
1082The stream "id" can be left out if there is only one stream in the
1083trace. The event "id" field can be left out if there is only one event
1084in a stream.
1085
1086trace {
1087 major = value; /* Trace format version */
1088 minor = value;
1089 uuid = "aaaaaaaa-aaaa-aaaa-aaaa-aaaaaaaaaaaa"; /* Trace UUID */
1090 byte_order = be OR le; /* Endianness (required) */
1091 packet.header := struct {
1092 uint32_t magic;
1093 uint8_t uuid[16];
1094 uint32_t stream_id;
1095 };
1096};
1097
1098stream {
1099 id = stream_id;
1100 /* Type 1 - Few event IDs; Type 2 - Many event IDs. See section 6.1. */
1101 event.header := event_header_1 OR event_header_2;
1102 event.context := struct {
1103 ...
1104 };
1105 packet.context := struct {
1106 ...
1107 };
1108};
1109
1110event {
1111 name = event_name;
1112 id = value; /* Numeric identifier within the stream */
1113 stream_id = stream_id;
1114 context := struct {
1115 ...
1116 };
1117 fields := struct {
1118 ...
1119 };
1120};
1121
1122/* More detail on types in section 4. Types */
1123
1124/*
1125 * Named types:
1126 *
1127 * Type declarations behave similarly to the C standard.
1128 */
1129
1130typedef aliased_type_specifiers new_type_declarators;
1131
1132/* e.g.: typedef struct example new_type_name[10]; */
1133
1134/*
1135 * typealias
1136 *
1137 * The "typealias" declaration can be used to give a name (including
1138 * pointer declarator specifier) to a type. It should also be used to
1139 * map basic C types (float, int, unsigned long, ...) to a CTF type.
1140 * Typealias is a superset of "typedef": it also allows assignment of a
1141 * simple variable identifier to a type.
1142 */
1143
1144typealias type_class {
1145 ...
1146} := type_specifiers type_declarator;
1147
1148/*
1149 * e.g.:
1150 * typealias integer {
1151 * size = 32;
1152 * align = 32;
1153 * signed = false;
1154 * } := struct page *;
1155 *
1156 * typealias integer {
1157 * size = 32;
1158 * align = 32;
1159 * signed = true;
1160 * } := int;
1161 */
1162
1163struct name {
1164 ...
1165};
1166
1167variant name {
1168 ...
1169};
1170
1171enum name : integer_type {
1172 ...
1173};
1174
1175
1176/*
1177 * Unnamed types, contained within compound type fields, typedef or typealias.
1178 */
1179
1180struct {
1181 ...
1182}
1183
1184struct {
1185 ...
1186} align(value)
1187
1188variant {
1189 ...
1190}
1191
1192enum : integer_type {
1193 ...
1194}
1195
1196typedef type new_type[length];
1197
1198struct {
1199 type field_name[length];
1200}
1201
1202typedef type new_type[length_type];
1203
1204struct {
1205 type field_name[length_type];
1206}
1207
1208integer {
1209 ...
1210}
1211
1212floating_point {
1213 ...
1214}
1215
1216struct {
1217 integer_type field_name:size; /* GNU/C bitfield */
1218}
1219
1220struct {
1221 string field_name;
1222}
1223
1224
1225A. Helper macros
1226
1227The two following macros keep track of the size of a GNU/C structure without
1228padding at the end by placing HEADER_END as the last field. A one byte end field
1229is used for C90 compatibility (C99 flexible arrays could be used here). Note
1230that this does not affect the effective structure size, which should always be
1231calculated with the header_sizeof() helper.
1232
1233#define HEADER_END char end_field
1234#define header_sizeof(type) offsetof(typeof(type), end_field)
1235
1236
1237B. Stream Header Rationale
1238
1239An event stream is divided in contiguous event packets of variable size. These
1240subdivisions allow the trace analyzer to perform a fast binary search by time
1241within the stream (typically requiring to index only the event packet headers)
1242without reading the whole stream. These subdivisions have a variable size to
1243eliminate the need to transfer the event packet padding when partially filled
1244event packets must be sent when streaming a trace for live viewing/analysis.
1245An event packet can contain a certain amount of padding at the end. Dividing
1246streams into event packets is also useful for network streaming over UDP and
1247flight recorder mode tracing (a whole event packet can be swapped out of the
1248buffer atomically for reading).
1249
1250The stream header is repeated at the beginning of each event packet to allow
1251flexibility in terms of:
1252
1253 - streaming support,
1254 - allowing arbitrary buffers to be discarded without making the trace
1255 unreadable,
1256 - allow UDP packet loss handling by either dealing with missing event packet
1257 or asking for re-transmission.
1258 - transparently support flight recorder mode,
1259 - transparently support crash dump.
1260
1261
1262C. TSDL Grammar
1263
1264/*
1265 * Common Trace Format (CTF) Trace Stream Description Language (TSDL) Grammar.
1266 *
1267 * Inspired from the C99 grammar:
1268 * http://www.open-std.org/jtc1/sc22/wg14/www/docs/n1124.pdf (Annex A)
1269 * and c++1x grammar (draft)
1270 * http://www.open-std.org/jtc1/sc22/wg21/docs/papers/2011/n3291.pdf (Annex A)
1271 *
1272 * Specialized for CTF needs by including only constant and declarations from
1273 * C99 (excluding function declarations), and by adding support for variants,
1274 * sequences and CTF-specific specifiers. Enumeration container types
1275 * semantic is inspired from c++1x enum-base.
1276 */
1277
12781) Lexical grammar
1279
12801.1) Lexical elements
1281
1282token:
1283 keyword
1284 identifier
1285 constant
1286 string-literal
1287 punctuator
1288
12891.2) Keywords
1290
1291keyword: is one of
1292
1293align
1294const
1295char
1296double
1297enum
1298event
1299floating_point
1300float
1301integer
1302int
1303long
1304short
1305signed
1306stream
1307string
1308struct
1309trace
1310typealias
1311typedef
1312unsigned
1313variant
1314void
1315_Bool
1316_Complex
1317_Imaginary
1318
1319
13201.3) Identifiers
1321
1322identifier:
1323 identifier-nondigit
1324 identifier identifier-nondigit
1325 identifier digit
1326
1327identifier-nondigit:
1328 nondigit
1329 universal-character-name
1330 any other implementation-defined characters
1331
1332nondigit:
1333 _
1334 [a-zA-Z] /* regular expression */
1335
1336digit:
1337 [0-9] /* regular expression */
1338
13391.4) Universal character names
1340
1341universal-character-name:
1342 \u hex-quad
1343 \U hex-quad hex-quad
1344
1345hex-quad:
1346 hexadecimal-digit hexadecimal-digit hexadecimal-digit hexadecimal-digit
1347
13481.5) Constants
1349
1350constant:
1351 integer-constant
1352 enumeration-constant
1353 character-constant
1354
1355integer-constant:
1356 decimal-constant integer-suffix-opt
1357 octal-constant integer-suffix-opt
1358 hexadecimal-constant integer-suffix-opt
1359
1360decimal-constant:
1361 nonzero-digit
1362 decimal-constant digit
1363
1364octal-constant:
1365 0
1366 octal-constant octal-digit
1367
1368hexadecimal-constant:
1369 hexadecimal-prefix hexadecimal-digit
1370 hexadecimal-constant hexadecimal-digit
1371
1372hexadecimal-prefix:
1373 0x
1374 0X
1375
1376nonzero-digit:
1377 [1-9]
1378
1379integer-suffix:
1380 unsigned-suffix long-suffix-opt
1381 unsigned-suffix long-long-suffix
1382 long-suffix unsigned-suffix-opt
1383 long-long-suffix unsigned-suffix-opt
1384
1385unsigned-suffix:
1386 u
1387 U
1388
1389long-suffix:
1390 l
1391 L
1392
1393long-long-suffix:
1394 ll
1395 LL
1396
1397enumeration-constant:
1398 identifier
1399 string-literal
1400
1401character-constant:
1402 ' c-char-sequence '
1403 L' c-char-sequence '
1404
1405c-char-sequence:
1406 c-char
1407 c-char-sequence c-char
1408
1409c-char:
1410 any member of source charset except single-quote ('), backslash
1411 (\), or new-line character.
1412 escape-sequence
1413
1414escape-sequence:
1415 simple-escape-sequence
1416 octal-escape-sequence
1417 hexadecimal-escape-sequence
1418 universal-character-name
1419
1420simple-escape-sequence: one of
1421 \' \" \? \\ \a \b \f \n \r \t \v
1422
1423octal-escape-sequence:
1424 \ octal-digit
1425 \ octal-digit octal-digit
1426 \ octal-digit octal-digit octal-digit
1427
1428hexadecimal-escape-sequence:
1429 \x hexadecimal-digit
1430 hexadecimal-escape-sequence hexadecimal-digit
1431
14321.6) String literals
1433
1434string-literal:
1435 " s-char-sequence-opt "
1436 L" s-char-sequence-opt "
1437
1438s-char-sequence:
1439 s-char
1440 s-char-sequence s-char
1441
1442s-char:
1443 any member of source charset except double-quote ("), backslash
1444 (\), or new-line character.
1445 escape-sequence
1446
14471.7) Punctuators
1448
1449punctuator: one of
1450 [ ] ( ) { } . -> * + - < > : ; ... = ,
1451
1452
14532) Phrase structure grammar
1454
1455primary-expression:
1456 identifier
1457 constant
1458 string-literal
1459 ( unary-expression )
1460
1461postfix-expression:
1462 primary-expression
1463 postfix-expression [ unary-expression ]
1464 postfix-expression . identifier
1465 postfix-expressoin -> identifier
1466
1467unary-expression:
1468 postfix-expression
1469 unary-operator postfix-expression
1470
1471unary-operator: one of
1472 + -
1473
1474assignment-operator:
1475 =
1476
1477type-assignment-operator:
1478 :=
1479
1480constant-expression-range:
1481 unary-expression ... unary-expression
1482
14832.2) Declarations:
1484
1485declaration:
1486 declaration-specifiers declarator-list-opt ;
1487 ctf-specifier ;
1488
1489declaration-specifiers:
1490 storage-class-specifier declaration-specifiers-opt
1491 type-specifier declaration-specifiers-opt
1492 type-qualifier declaration-specifiers-opt
1493
1494declarator-list:
1495 declarator
1496 declarator-list , declarator
1497
1498abstract-declarator-list:
1499 abstract-declarator
1500 abstract-declarator-list , abstract-declarator
1501
1502storage-class-specifier:
1503 typedef
1504
1505type-specifier:
1506 void
1507 char
1508 short
1509 int
1510 long
1511 float
1512 double
1513 signed
1514 unsigned
1515 _Bool
1516 _Complex
1517 _Imaginary
1518 struct-specifier
1519 variant-specifier
1520 enum-specifier
1521 typedef-name
1522 ctf-type-specifier
1523
1524align-attribute:
1525 align ( unary-expression )
1526
1527struct-specifier:
1528 struct identifier-opt { struct-or-variant-declaration-list-opt } align-attribute-opt
1529 struct identifier align-attribute-opt
1530
1531struct-or-variant-declaration-list:
1532 struct-or-variant-declaration
1533 struct-or-variant-declaration-list struct-or-variant-declaration
1534
1535struct-or-variant-declaration:
1536 specifier-qualifier-list struct-or-variant-declarator-list ;
1537 declaration-specifiers-opt storage-class-specifier declaration-specifiers-opt declarator-list ;
1538 typealias declaration-specifiers abstract-declarator-list type-assignment-operator declaration-specifiers abstract-declarator-list ;
1539 typealias declaration-specifiers abstract-declarator-list type-assignment-operator declarator-list ;
1540
1541specifier-qualifier-list:
1542 type-specifier specifier-qualifier-list-opt
1543 type-qualifier specifier-qualifier-list-opt
1544
1545struct-or-variant-declarator-list:
1546 struct-or-variant-declarator
1547 struct-or-variant-declarator-list , struct-or-variant-declarator
1548
1549struct-or-variant-declarator:
1550 declarator
1551 declarator-opt : unary-expression
1552
1553variant-specifier:
1554 variant identifier-opt variant-tag-opt { struct-or-variant-declaration-list }
1555 variant identifier variant-tag
1556
1557variant-tag:
1558 < unary-expression >
1559
1560enum-specifier:
1561 enum identifier-opt { enumerator-list }
1562 enum identifier-opt { enumerator-list , }
1563 enum identifier
1564 enum identifier-opt : declaration-specifiers { enumerator-list }
1565 enum identifier-opt : declaration-specifiers { enumerator-list , }
1566
1567enumerator-list:
1568 enumerator
1569 enumerator-list , enumerator
1570
1571enumerator:
1572 enumeration-constant
1573 enumeration-constant assignment-operator unary-expression
1574 enumeration-constant assignment-operator constant-expression-range
1575
1576type-qualifier:
1577 const
1578
1579declarator:
1580 pointer-opt direct-declarator
1581
1582direct-declarator:
1583 identifier
1584 ( declarator )
1585 direct-declarator [ unary-expression ]
1586
1587abstract-declarator:
1588 pointer-opt direct-abstract-declarator
1589
1590direct-abstract-declarator:
1591 identifier-opt
1592 ( abstract-declarator )
1593 direct-abstract-declarator [ unary-expression ]
1594 direct-abstract-declarator [ ]
1595
1596pointer:
1597 * type-qualifier-list-opt
1598 * type-qualifier-list-opt pointer
1599
1600type-qualifier-list:
1601 type-qualifier
1602 type-qualifier-list type-qualifier
1603
1604typedef-name:
1605 identifier
1606
16072.3) CTF-specific declarations
1608
1609ctf-specifier:
1610 event { ctf-assignment-expression-list-opt }
1611 stream { ctf-assignment-expression-list-opt }
1612 trace { ctf-assignment-expression-list-opt }
1613 typealias declaration-specifiers abstract-declarator-list type-assignment-operator declaration-specifiers abstract-declarator-list
1614 typealias declaration-specifiers abstract-declarator-list type-assignment-operator declarator-list
1615
1616ctf-type-specifier:
1617 floating_point { ctf-assignment-expression-list-opt }
1618 integer { ctf-assignment-expression-list-opt }
1619 string { ctf-assignment-expression-list-opt }
1620 string
1621
1622ctf-assignment-expression-list:
1623 ctf-assignment-expression ;
1624 ctf-assignment-expression-list ctf-assignment-expression ;
1625
1626ctf-assignment-expression:
1627 unary-expression assignment-operator unary-expression
1628 unary-expression type-assignment-operator type-specifier
1629 declaration-specifiers-opt storage-class-specifier declaration-specifiers-opt declarator-list
1630 typealias declaration-specifiers abstract-declarator-list type-assignment-operator declaration-specifiers abstract-declarator-list
1631 typealias declaration-specifiers abstract-declarator-list type-assignment-operator declarator-list
This page took 0.027617 seconds and 4 git commands to generate.